Slow Burn
Summary
Dateline NBC investigates the 2018 murders of Keith Canero and his family in New Jersey, linking the crime to a suspicious fire at his brother Paul’s home. Prosecutors argue Paul killed them for greed and insurance money, while the defense claims police tunnel vision ignored other suspects. The episode covers the investigation, trial, and Paul’s eventual guilty verdict for four counts of murder and arson.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and intro
The nightmare fire at the Canaro home
The Canaro family and their community
Emergency response to the fire
Discovery of Keith Canaro's body
Finding Jennifer, Jesse, and Sophia
The family's life and relationships
Business rivalry between the brothers
Sponsors
Evidence of arson at both homes
Paul Canaro becomes the prime suspect
Paul's arrest and initial reaction
Community mourning and sponsors
Prosecution's case: Financial motive
Timeline of the murders and arson
Defense arguments and alternative suspects
Verdict and aftermath
Listen ad-free on Castria