Dateline NBC Dateline NBC

Out of the Darkness

Jul 7, 2026 · 41m

Summary

Dateline investigates the 2016 murder of Texas firefighter Bob Pointer, whose wife Chasey claimed a stranger shot him. Police discovered Chasey conspired with her lover, Michael Garza, to kill Bob for his life insurance money. Garza was sentenced to 99 years, while Chasey received life in prison with parole eligibility after the jury rejected the capital murder charge.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Insurance and Capital One Dateline Intro: A Mystery on a Desolate Road The 911 Call and Police Response Discovery of the Body and Initial Scene Victim Profile: Fire Captain Bob Pointer Chasey's Background and Troubled Marriage Crime Scene Investigation and Clues Sponsors: SNHU, Ozempic, and Grainger Chasey's Account of the Shooting Inconsistencies in Chasey's Story Blood Evidence and Introduction of Michael Garza Garza's Alibi and Chasey's Confession Family Reaction and Manhunt for Garza Sponsors: Ozempic and Taboola Garza Surrenders and Murder Weapon Found The Trial: Text Messages and Guilty Verdicts Chasey's Trial: Defense of Abuse vs. Prosecution Motive: Affairs, Divorce, and Life Insurance Verdict, Sentencing, and Family's Grief Sponsors: ZepBound
Listen ad-free on Castria