No Ordinary Sunday
Summary
This episode investigates the 2001 disappearance of Nikki McCown, a 28-year-old bride-to-be who vanished in Richmond, Indiana. Host Josh Mankowitz explores the case with Nikki’s daughter Peyton and sister Michelle, examining suspicious behavior by her fiancé and a coworker, Tommy Swint, who was later linked to another murder. Despite Swint’s suicide and the passage of decades, the family remains determined to find answers and bring Nikki home.
Topics discussed
Intro: Ads and episode overview
Nikki McCown's life and family in Richmond
The Sunday before: Wedding plans and routine
Nikki's last known movements at the laundromat
The search begins and family's reaction
Surveillance footage and ruling out voluntary departure
Fiance Bobby Webster's timeline and alibi
Suspicion falls on Bobby; car found months later
Investigating ex-fiance Stephen and the car location
Tommy Swint emerges as a suspect
DNA links Tommy to another murder; his suicide
The case remains unsolved; family's grief
Legacy, advocacy, and call for information
Listen ad-free on Castria