Darknet Diaries Darknet Diaries

176: NSL

National Security Letter Fbi Lawsuit

Jul 7, 2026 · 1h 6m

Summary

Host Jack Rhysider interviews Nick Merrill, who recounts receiving a National Security Letter from the FBI demanding customer data without a warrant. Merrill, advised by the ACLU, sued the government, arguing the letter violated his First, Fourth, and Fifth Amendment rights. After years of litigation and government appeals, the FBI withdrew the letter to dismiss the case, though a settlement eventually lifted Merrill's gag order, allowing him to share this story of constitutional resistance.

Topics discussed

Intro: The origin of automatic telephone switching Sponsors: ThreatLocker and Maze Nick Merrill's background and interest in constitutional law Founding Calix ISP and early internet adoption Receiving the National Security Letter from the FBI Analyzing the legality of the NSL and gag order Filing Doe v. Ashcroft with the NYCLU Sponsor: NetSuite The legal battle, stays, and eventual settlement Cindy Cohn and EFF's fight against NSLs Legislative changes and the limits of litigation Privacy by design and the Freely mobile service

More from Darknet Diaries

182: Blackshades
Nov 3, 2026
181: Ricky
Oct 20, 2026
180: Conti
Oct 6, 2026
LOW - Now Available
Sep 22, 2026
179: The Courthouse - Revisited
Sep 1, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria