Author, Researcher, and paranormal storyteller Amelia Cotter: Haunted History, Ghost Stories & the Old Baraboo Inn
Sep 27, 2026 · 53m
Summary
Amelia Cotter discusses her lifelong passion for folklore and shares her first paranormal experience in a haunted Maryland home. She details the history and ghost stories behind the Old Baraboo Inn, including the Al Capone legend and physical manifestations like floating lights. Cotter also reflects on how deep research can influence her writing and recounts eerie encounters while compiling her books.
Topics discussed
Introduction and guest bio
Childhood ghost stories and early experiences
First paranormal encounter in Maryland
Receptivity to paranormal and investigation styles
The phantom house at Bachelors Grove Cemetery
History of Bachelors Grove and current access
Researching hauntings: history vs. folklore
Origin story of the Old Baraboo Inn book
Notable ghost photos and sightings at the Inn
Book title and a specific ghost story
Researching the Demon House in Indiana
Experiencing the weight of research and writing
The Maryland house and Walter's House history
Spooky Story Boutique podcast and other media
TV appearances and Midwest mystery history
Frank Lloyd Wright and local history
Children's book and reading list
Cryptids: Bigfoot and Mothman in Illinois
Bucket list locations and closing remarks
Where to find the guest and sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria