Critics at Large | The New Yorker Critics at Large | The New Yorker

Tom Cruise-a-Palooza

Oct 1, 2026 · 56m

Summary

Hosts Alex Schwartz, Nomi Fry, and Vincent Cunningham discuss Tom Cruise’s enduring status as the last true movie star, analyzing his career arc from early heartthrob roles to action hero dominance. They examine his new film Digger, debating its satirical merits and Cruise’s performance, while exploring how his Scientology affiliation and personal eccentricities shape his public image. The episode features New Yorker senior editor Tyler Foggatt, who categorizes Cruise’s filmography and shares her personal history as a lifelong fan.

Topics discussed

Introduction and upcoming episodes Why Tom Cruise has such a cultural pull Guest introduction: Tyler Foggatt Tyler's personal connection to Tom Cruise Categorizing Cruise's filmography into buckets Analyzing 'Risky Business' and early persona The 'cocky' charisma of the 90s era Discussion of 'Jerry Maguire' Cruise as a comedian and dramatic actor Role in 'Magnolia' and working with auteurs The Oscar snub and transition to action Scientology and the 'War of the Worlds' era The 'Savior' complex in Cruise's roles Sponsorship and transition to film review Hosts' initial reactions to 'Digger' The meta-narrative twist in 'Digger' Debate on the satire and performances Tyler's critique of 'Digger' as a failure Future of Cruise's career and upcoming films Sponsorship and break Is Tom Cruise the last movie star? Conclusion and sponsorships
Listen ad-free on Castria