Critics at Large | The New Yorker Critics at Large | The New Yorker

That Back-to-School Feeling

Sep 17, 2026 · 46m

Summary

Hosts Nomi Fry, Vincent Cunningham, and Alex Schwartz discuss the back-to-school season, responding to listener questions about combating student apathy, the emotional realities of teaching, and the value of poetry. They recommend texts like *A Complicated Kindness* and *The Great Gatsby*, while sharing personal anecdotes about classroom dynamics and the performance aspect of education. The episode also features a heartfelt farewell to departing editor Alex Barish.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: ChatGPT Work Nostalgia for the first day of school Episode overview: Back to school themes Listener voicemail: High school teacher's apathy Discussion: Combating student apathy Teaching as performance and establishing boundaries Book recommendations: The Great Gatsby Book recommendation: A Complicated Kindness Sponsor: Bon Appétit Bake Club News segment: Surrogate scandal Introduction to the Critic series Panel discussion: Switching from student to teacher Listener voicemail: Media for new teachers Movie recommendation: The Holdovers Movie recommendation: The Class Movie recommendation: Dead Poets Society Sponsor: ChatGPT Work Sponsor: Bon Appétit Bake Club Sponsor: GQ One More Question Poetry: Reading Langston Hughes Poetry: Discussion on voice and relatability Poetry: Reading Kelly Link Poetry: Reading Sharon Olds Poetry: Reading Jane Kenyon Closing remarks and credits Sponsor: ChatGPT Work Sponsor: GQ One More Question Sponsor: Vogue Run Through
Listen ad-free on Castria