Critics at Large | The New Yorker Critics at Large | The New Yorker

Introducing: “The Journey,” from In the Dark

Sep 20, 2026 · 56m

Summary

Investigative reporter Ava Kaufman explores a scandal involving a wealthy Los Angeles couple who used their own surrogacy agency to recruit dozens of women across the country. The episode follows surrogate Kayla Elliott and others who discover the couple had 21 children, not the one or two they were told. As the intended parents face child endangerment charges and their children are taken into foster care, the surrogates navigate legal limbo, questioning their contracts and the unregulated nature of the industry.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Rocket Mortgage Sponsor: ChatGPT Work Introduction to Kayla and her surrogacy journey The emerging scandal and industry loopholes Meeting Kayla and Blake in Corpus Christi Motivations for becoming a surrogate Matching with intended parents Guo and Sylvia Hormone injections and communication issues Embryo transfer and meeting the father Financial benefits and emotional detachment Kayla's medical complications and labor Birth of the baby and Sylvia's arrival Post-birth emotions and meeting Sylvia Discovering other surrogates for the same couple Suspicion of child trafficking Kayla's story goes viral Surrogates connect and contact the FBI Sylvia's evasive phone calls Kayla learns of the parents' arrest Other surrogates still pregnant Stacy King's panic and legal advice Navigating authorities and custody questions Preparing for potential custody of babies Stacy's recorded conversation with Sylvia Police affidavit reveals abuse and unlicensed daycare Surrogates decide to keep the babies Legal defense and series credits Outro and call to action Sponsor: Avatar Fire and Ash
Listen ad-free on Castria