Critical Darlings Critical Darlings

“One Night Only” Is The Sex Purge (With Josh Gondelman)

Aug 13, 2026 · 1h 33m

Summary

Hosts Richard Lawson and Alison Romer, joined by guest Josh Gundelman, review the romantic comedy *One Night Only*. They critique its "Sex Purge" premise, where a fascist government allows single people to have sex for one night, arguing the film fails to satirize its own absurd setup. The discussion covers the movie’s weak box office, the leads' chemistry, and how the high-concept plot undermines the traditional rom-com structure.

Topics discussed

Intro, hosts, and initial thoughts on the film's title and premise The dystopian setting, biometric tattoos, and fascist government backdrop Comparisons to The Purge and the exclusion of queer characters The Hollywood Blacklist and high-concept script trends Lead performances: Callum Turner's charm and character arc Monica Barbaro's character, backstory, and the meet-cute Rom-com tropes, chemistry, and director Will Gluck's style The condom subplot and the film's refusal to explain the premise The film as a metaphor for COVID restrictions and trauma Spoiler discussion: The ending, sex-negative themes, and FOMO Cameos, New York setting, and supporting cast performances Theatrical viability, movie recommendations, and outro
Listen ad-free on Castria