She Killed Three People with Poisonous Mushrooms. Did She Mean To?
Summary
Host Phoebe Judge interviews Guardian Australia reporter Nino Bucci about the trial of Erin Patterson, who poisoned her in-laws with death cap mushrooms in beef Wellington. Three guests died while Patterson survived, leading to charges of murder and attempted murder. The episode details the investigation, Patterson’s claim of accidental foraging, and her eventual guilty verdict and 33-year sentence.
Topics discussed
Intro: Ukraine military shakeup and podcast promo
The fatal lunch: Erin Patterson hosts in-laws for beef Wellington
Beef Wellington recipe and the mushroom ingredient
Guests fall ill and are diagnosed with death cap poisoning
The horrific effects of death cap mushroom toxicity
Erin's strange behavior and delayed hospital visit
Three deaths, one survivor, and the police investigation
Erin's initial denial and baffled response to police
Ad break: Odoo business software
Ad break: Fashion Neurosis with RM from BTS
Erin's estranged relationship with her husband Simon
Police evidence contradicting Erin's alibi
Charges, dropped Simon charges, and the trial focus
The emotional trial and Erin's testimony
Prosecution theory on sourcing the poisonous mushrooms
Erin's defense: accidental poisoning claim
Guilty verdict and 33-year sentence
Motive speculation and Simon's book deal
Outro: Appeal details and show notes
Listen ad-free on Castria