Criminal Criminal

Raynella, Part 2

Nov 20, 2026 · 39m

Summary

This episode details the legal saga of Raynella Dossett Leith, who was convicted of murdering her second husband before being acquitted in a third trial. The narrative explores the conflicting evidence regarding whether David Leith died by suicide or murder, alongside revelations of Raynella’s alleged attempted murder of a man who discovered her first husband’s paternity secret. The story concludes with the judge dismissing the case after finding the prosecution failed to prove Raynella’s guilt, leaving her free until her death in 2026.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Iamate and Helix Phoebe promotes her live show 'Don't Worry' Episode context and content warnings First trial: The murder accusation and courtroom setup Defense argument: Suicide and David's mental state Prosecution theory: Drugging and staged scene Forensic evidence: Gun, bullets, and death spasms The alibi, the breakfast tray, and motive First trial verdict: Hung jury and mistrial Revelation: The affair and the barn incident Sponsors: Talkiatry and Quince The shooting of Steve Walker and plea deal Second trial: New evidence on first husband's death Second trial verdict: Guilty and life sentence Life in prison and the judge's scandal Sponsors: Mint Mobile and ARCA Wealth Judge's addiction and new defense evidence Third trial: Jury selection and courtroom demonstrations The judge's surprise acquittal of Raynella Aftermath, legacy, and Raynella's death Credits, membership, and final sponsor

More from Criminal

Raynella, Part 1
Nov 13, 2026
A Prime Minister's Murder, a Cult Expert, and the Moonies
Nov 10, 2026
Northernmost
Nov 6, 2026
Road Rage (Please Continue)
Oct 30, 2026
She Says Her Husband Cheated. The Law Won’t Let Her Divorce Him for a Year (with Jen Hamilton)
Oct 27, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria