Not Criminally Responsible
Summary
This episode details the 1992 parricide of George and Dorothy Bechtold by their son Brian, who was found not criminally responsible due to paranoid schizophrenia. Narrated by author Maqueda Brodman, the story follows Brian’s decades-long confinement at Maryland’s Clifton Perkins State Hospital, where he faced escalating security levels and heavy medication. After a failed escape attempt and a subsequent lawsuit to secure his release, Brian remains institutionalized despite independent psychiatric evaluations deeming him safe for community reintegration.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and tour announcement
Brian Bechtold turns himself in for murder
Background: Abusive family and childhood trauma
Mental health decline and early adulthood struggles
Paranoia, isolation, and the night of the murders
Sponsors: Mint Mobile and NetSuite
Psychotic state, Bible reading, and police discovery
Family reaction, legal defense, and NCR verdict
Life at Clifton Perkins State Hospital
Medication issues and decision to escape
Sponsors: Grüns and Shopify
The 1999 escape attempt and police shooting
Post-escape consequences and 2002 trial
Lung mass, refusal of treatment, and legal battles
Maita Brodman's perspective and 2014 lawsuit
Current status, lack of support, and dehumanization
Credits, membership, and final sponsors
Listen ad-free on Castria