Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Witch-Hunt: Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror In Hiding

Sep 26, 2026 · 34m

Summary

Nancy Grace examines the ongoing harassment of Patrick Clancy, father of the three children strangled by his wife Lindsay, as internet trolls push baseless conspiracy theories. Experts, including Dr. Bethany Marshall and forensic professor Joe Scott Morgan, debunk these claims and explain the gruesome forensic evidence of ligature strangulation. The episode also covers the legal battle involving defense attorney Kevin Redington’s motion to investigate the holdout juror, who is now in hiding after facing threats for his verdict.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Hers weight loss medications Sponsors: AirTasker and Lingo Kids Sponsor: YouTube Premium and show intro Lindsey Clancy juror goes into hiding Patrick Clancy's grief and internet trolls Dr. Marshall on juror psychology and civil trial Josh Colsher on jury nullification and bias Juror statement on voting for women's future Debunking the CVS hoodie conspiracy theory Criticism of Patrick Clancy's new relationship Sponsors: AirTasker, Lingo Kids, Grand Canyon University Sponsor: Just Food For Dogs Guests defend Patrick Clancy's right to move on Joe Scott Morgan on the reality of death investigation Forensic details of ligature strangulation Analysis of Clancy's demeanor and public scrutiny Dr. Marshall on the insanity defense and command hallucinations Shannon Hill on lack of evidence for affair Legal debate on investigating the holdout juror Closing thoughts on rule of law and call to action
Listen ad-free on Castria