Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Teen Son’s Sick Obsession w/ Mom: Who Murdered Mom Jessica & Eli, 8?

Sep 8, 2026 · 41m

Summary

Nancy Grace investigates the 2024 murders of Jessica Lyman and her 8-year-old son Eli in Utah, where 16-year-old Noah was arrested after investigators found gunshot residue on his clothes and disturbing evidence of a sexual obsession with his mother. The episode features forensic experts and psychoanalysts who discuss the bizarre crime scene details, including seminal fluid and fishnet stockings, alongside Noah’s hateful text messages to his mother. Guests analyze the psychological dynamics of maternal fixation and resentment, noting that while the son claimed he slept through the incident,…

Topics discussed

Sponsors: TD Bank, One Times Square, Disney on Ice Case Overview: Mother and son found dead in Utah Dr. Bethany Marshall on disturbing forensic details Analysis of hateful texts and motive Legal and investigative perspectives on evidence Discovery of bodies and the 911 call Police procedure and securing the crime scene Sponsors: One Times Square and Disney on Ice Son's police interview and claim of sleeping Psychological profile: Resentment and family dynamics Comparison to similar cases: Derek Rosa Comparison to similar cases: Sarah Grace Patrick Comparison to similar cases: Carly Gregg Sponsors: TD Bank, One Times Square, Disney on Ice Surveillance footage and circumstantial evidence Forensic analysis: Gunshot residue and DNA GSR evidence and potential motives Audio surveillance: Argument and gunshots Sponsors: TD Bank, One Times Square, Disney on Ice
Listen ad-free on Castria