Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

KEY WITNESS IN PASTOR’S WIFE MICA MILLER CASE DEAD

Sep 12, 2026 · 37m

Summary

Nancy Grace examines the federal indictment of Pastor John Paul Miller for cyberstalking his wife, Micah, who was found dead at Lumber River State Park. The episode features legal experts and investigators analyzing the charges, which include posting nude photos, using tracking devices, and deflating tires, while debating whether Miller drove Micah to suicide. Guests discuss the lack of a proper crime scene investigation, the validity of enhanced 911 call audio, and Miller’s recent public outbursts and new relationship. The panel also highlights South Carolina’s legal gaps regarding non-con…

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Hers weight loss medications Sponsors: AirTasker, Lingo Kids, Disney on Ice Intro: Pastor Miller walks free on cyber stalking charges Alexis Tereschuk details federal indictment specifics Timeline of Micah Miller's death at Lumber River Civil lawsuit and public reaction outside courthouse Discussion on ankle monitor conditions and credibility Rumors of Miller dating a new woman after death Detective Barry Hutchinson analyzes Miller's behavior Sponsors: AirTasker, Lingo Kids, Disney on Ice, One Times Square Lauren Collin on church emptying and public scrutiny Video: Miller's tantrum and incoherent statements Dr. Bethany Marshall analyzes Miller's psychological state Witness testimony and enhanced 911 call analysis Claudia King on the significance of background whispering Sponsors: AirTasker, Lingo Kids, Disney on Ice, One Times Square Regina Ward: Family's perspective and investigation flaws Precedent: Michelle Carter and driving to suicide Regina Ward on coercive control and baiting tactics Breakdown of federal charges and harassment counts Discussion on revenge porn laws and tracking photos Jennifer Wood on local law enforcement inaction Sponsors: AirTasker, Lingo Kids, Disney on Ice, One Times Square
Listen ad-free on Castria