Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

FLOODGATES OPEN: CLANCY CHATROOM MOM CALLS SON, 2, “ANTICHRIST,” KILLS HIM?

Sep 10, 2026 · 34m

Summary

Nancy Grace discusses the Lindsay Clancy mistrial, highlighting defense attorney Kevin Reddington’s controversial attacks on the holdout juror and his request for a presidential pardon. The episode also covers a suspected copycat case in Frankfort, Illinois, where a mother obsessed with the Clancy trial allegedly hanged her two-year-old son. Experts analyze the similarities between the two cases, debating the validity of the "psychotic break" defense against evidence of premeditation and organized behavior.

Topics discussed

Sponsorships and show introduction Lindsay Clancy trial declared a mistrial Defense attorney attacks holdout juror Report on Corey Walsh hanging her son Barrett Dr. Bethany Marshall on copycat potential Mark Astor compares the two cases Discussion on malingering and psychiatric claims Clancy's suicide attempt and defense statements Reddington defends juror attack on GMA Shannon Hill on juror identity and next steps Forensic analysis of Barrett's death Psychological profile of Corey Walsh Viral videos of postpartum intrusive thoughts Forensic details on asphyxial deaths Airtasker sponsorship break Mark Astor on retrial and premeditation Evidence of planning in the Clancy case Post-homicide behavior and planning Viewing children as sociopathic or evil Debate on motive and burden of proof Forensic details on Clancy children's deaths Closing remarks and contact information
Listen ad-free on Castria