Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan: Missing Women, Philly House Of Horrors! Dissolving Bodies & Snuff Films

Sep 6, 2026 · 53m

Summary

Hosts Joseph Scott Morgan and Brother Dave investigate the "House of Horrors" in Philadelphia’s Olney neighborhood, where a routine traffic stop led to the arrest of Eugene Horsch. Investigators discovered weapons, drugs, a fake DEA ID, and a chemical lab containing 55-gallon drums connected to the sewer system. Authorities have identified four missing women, including Blair Tonselli, and recovered photos and videos suggesting their deaths. The case involves complex federal charges, potential evidence of human remains disposal, and a disturbing connection to Horsch’s late father, a known pr…

Topics discussed

Sponsors and introduction to the House of Horrors case Hosts discuss their approach to serial homicide cases The initial traffic stop and welfare check context Discovery of weapons and fake ID in the vehicle Historical context of the Philadelphia location Analysis of DEA credentials and firearm types Sponsor breaks and transition to home search Police entry into the home and initial observations Discovery of grow operation and federal jurisdiction ATF involvement and ballistic evidence database Media reaction and the 55-gallon drum discovery Comparison to past cases and federal lab processing Chemical laboratory findings and ongoing investigation The father's history with graphic and violent material Identification of missing women in photos and videos Forensic challenges in identifying dissolved remains Systematic evidence collection and DNA sampling Discovery of urns and questions about cremation Call for public information and closing thoughts Final sponsor reads and podcast outro
Listen ad-free on Castria