Crime Stories with Nancy Grace Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

3RD LINDSAY "CLANCY-STYLE" HOMICIDE, HOLDOUT JUROR ATTACK

Sep 19, 2026 · 39m

Summary

Nancy Grace examines the third "Clancy-style" filicide involving Jeanette McCauslin, who strangled her six and seven-year-old children before claiming a psychotic break. The episode features guests analyzing the "copycat" phenomenon, the Werther effect, and the chilling similarities between these cases. Additionally, the show addresses the intense public backlash and doxxing of the lone holdout juror in the original Lindsay Clancy trial, sparking debate on juror safety and the impact of media coverage on criminal justice.

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Hers weight loss medications Sponsors: Airtasker, Fencing, Disney on Ice Intro: Clancy juror attack and new copycat case Details on Jeanette McCauslin's confession and flight Analysis of McCauslin's actions and mental state Discussion on divorce, suicide attempt, and child deaths Defense attorney's statement on mental illness Dr. Carmichael on copycat and Werther effects McCauslin arraignment and legal procedure explained Dr. Coyne on the trauma of asphyxiation Sponsors: Airtasker, Fencing, Disney, One Times Square Marie Pereira: Comparing Clancy, Walsh, and McCauslin Social contagion and financial rewards for Clancy McCauslin lawyer seeks dismissal; Clancy fundraiser Clancy holdout juror doxxed and attacked Prosecutor response to juror criticism Discussion on juror intimidation and name leak Marie Pereira on juror rights and integrity Sponsors: Airtasker, Fencing, Disney, One Times Square Reddington's role in juror exposure and jury selection Dr. Coyne on pressure on medical examiners Closing: Tip lines, hero tribute, and legal burden Sponsors: Airtasker, Fencing, Disney, One Times Square
Listen ad-free on Castria