Unsolved: Tara Leigh Calico, The Polaroid Mystery
Summary
Hosts Sarah Turney and Courtney Nicole examine the 1988 disappearance of Tara Calico, who vanished during a bike ride in New Mexico. The episode details the discovery of a mysterious Polaroid photo found in Florida, which fueled decades of speculation and investigation. It also covers recent developments, including new suspects identified by investigators and the ongoing efforts to solve this haunting cold case.
Topics discussed
Intro, Crime House Plus promo, and episode overview
Ad: Sarah Turney and Courtney Nicole on private practice
Tara Colico's background, personality, and bright future
The morning of September 20, 1988: Tara's bike ride routine
Tara goes missing: Family search and police response
Discovery of the Walkman and initial witness accounts
The infamous Polaroid photo appears in Florida
FBI analysis, Michael Henley's case, and family beliefs
Sheriff Renee Rivera's theory and Henry Brown's confession
Discussion on accessing case files and family trauma
Modern investigation efforts and DNA leads
Reenactment of Tara's final moments and description
Outro, upcoming episodes, and sponsor promotions
Listen ad-free on Castria