Crime House 24/7 Crime House 24/7

Throwback Thursday: The Boy in the Box Pt. 1

Aug 13, 2026 · 29m

Summary

Host Vanessa Richardson revisits the 1957 "Boy in the Box" case, detailing the discovery of a murdered toddler in Philadelphia and the initial failed investigation. The episode covers the dead ends involving a hat, bassinet, and blanket, as well as investigator Remington Bristow’s decades-long obsession with the Nicoletti foster family theory. It concludes by noting how modern efforts have finally begun to identify the child after generations of mystery.

Topics discussed

Intro: Crimes of Reddit and Crime House 24-7 Sponsors: Weight Loss by HERS and Quince Discovery of the Boy in the Box in Philadelphia Initial Investigation and Autopsy Findings Sponsors: Earnest and Dateline Missing in America Tracing Clues: The Hat, Box, and Blanket Public Appeals and Failed Identification Attempts FBI Involvement and Burial as John Doe Sponsors: Wayfair, Alma, and Primally Pure Public Theories: Hungarian Refugee and Circus Family Remington Bristow's Obsession and Psychic Lead The Nicoletti Foster Home Theory and Legacy Outro: Crime House Plus and Mercury Banking
Listen ad-free on Castria