Archives: Did Alexandria Duval Murder Her Twin Sister?
Summary
This episode details the 2016 death of Anastasia Duval, whose identical twin sister Alexandria was charged with second-degree murder after their SUV went over a cliff in Hawaii. The prosecution argued the crash was intentional based on vehicle data showing acceleration and eyewitnesses who saw the sisters fighting, while the defense claimed Alexandria lost control due to Anastasia pulling her hair. After a bench trial, the judge acquitted Alexandria, ruling that the evidence did not prove intentional murder beyond a reasonable doubt. The host also discusses the twins' controversial history,…
Topics discussed
Sponsor: Progressive Insurance
Show Intro and Archive Episode Announcement
The Crash on Hana Highway and Initial Rescue
Alexandria's Reaction and Witness Accounts of Argument
Arrest, Charges, and Initial Dismissal
Background: The Daddow Twins and Yoga Business
History of Legal Troubles and Relocation to Hawaii
Media Coverage and New DUI Arrest
Grand Jury Indictment and Pre-Trial Motions
Trial Opening Statements: Prosecution vs Defense
Sponsor: LeafFilter
Witness Testimony: Officers and Eyewitnesses
Hospital Interactions and Identification of Victims
Eyewitness Accounts of the Pre-Crash Argument
Testimony of Anastasia's Boyfriend Federico Bailey
Accident Reconstruction Experts and Rebuttal
Judge's Verdict: Not Guilty
Legal Analysis with Former Prosecutor Peter Carlisle
Outro and Call to Action
Listen ad-free on Castria