Rewind: The Titanic
Jul 1, 2026 · 1h 2m
Summary
Host Carter Roy explores conspiracy theories surrounding the Titanic’s sinking, including claims that J.P. Morgan orchestrated the disaster to eliminate Federal Reserve opponents. The episode also examines Robin Gardner’s theory that the damaged Olympic was swapped with the Titanic for an insurance payout. Using historical records and modern simulations, the podcast debunks these myths, confirming the iceberg collision was accidental and the ships were not switched.
Topics discussed
Bob Ballard's 1985 discovery of the Titanic
Introduction to Conspiracy Theories podcast and Titanic episode
The Titanic's maiden voyage and collision with the iceberg
The sinking process, lifeboats, and rescue efforts
Post-disaster investigations and the ship breaking in two
J.P. Morgan conspiracy: Did he cause the sinking?
The Wreck of the Titan and other premonition theories
The Olympic-Titanic switcheroo insurance fraud theory
Super refraction and the Calypso's failure to respond
The 1996 James Cameron Titanic film set chowder incident
Conclusion, credits, and sponsor messages
Listen ad-free on Castria