Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes

CRIME: Hex Hollow: The York Witch Trial

Oct 30, 2026 · 44m

Summary

This episode recounts the 1928 murder of Nelson Raymeyer, a Pennsylvania Dutch folk healer, by John Blymeyer and two accomplices who believed Raymeyer had cast a hex on them. The story explores the cultural context of "powwow" healing and the role of a con artist in fueling Blymeyer's delusions, leading to the notorious "Witch of Hex Hollow" legend. It details the subsequent trials, where local authorities attempted to suppress the witchcraft motive, and concludes with the family's decades-long effort to restore Raymeyer's reputation as a healer rather than a witch.

Topics discussed

Black Friday Crime House Plus promotion The discovery of starving animals and a dark house The fire that died and the legend of the healer Show introduction and host welcome Content warnings for violence and death Episode preview: Folk healing and murder motives History of Powwow and Braukurai in Pennsylvania The Long Lost Friend and the dark side of healing Distinction between healers and witches in 1928 Nelson Raymeyer's life as a reclusive healer John Blymeyer's childhood illness and recovery John's belief in a hex and his search for the culprit Marriage, loss of a child, and renewed suspicion The deadly reputation of practitioner Lenhart John's institutionalization and divorce Consulting Emma Knopp to identify the witch The vision of Nelson's face on a dollar bill Recruiting Curry and the Hess family Preparations and the one-day delay The first attempt to steal the book fails Recruiting Wilbert Hess for the second attempt The murder of Nelson Raymeyer Conflicting accounts of who delivered the fatal blow The failed attempt to burn the body John's reaction and the Thanksgiving meal Neighbors discover the scene and call police Forensic findings and rapid police investigation Identification of suspects and national media attention Arrests and the suppression of witchcraft in court Courtroom restrictions and media ban Legal strategy to remove witchcraft from the case Charging robbery to avoid proving premeditation Judicial rulings on insanity and the word witch Defense arguments and character witnesses Sentencing and Will Rogers' criticism John's belief that the curse was broken Fates of the surviving defendants The legend of the unburnable body Local ghost stories and the Raymeyer house Modern myths of Satanism and sacrifice Nelson's burial as a Christian healer A descendant's apology at the grave Reflections on the transformation into a ghost story Closing thoughts on the case Show outro and support request Crime House Plus subscription details Black Friday promotion repeat

More from Conspiracy Theories, Cults, & Crimes

Thanksgiving EXTRA: The UnBelievable - Sweet Revenge
Nov 21, 2026
CRIME: Tara Calico & the Polaroid
Nov 20, 2026
CULT: David Berg & The Children of God
Nov 18, 2026
CONSPIRACY THEORY: The Curse in the Basin: Skinwalkers and the $22 Million Secret
Nov 16, 2026
CRIME: Ricky McCormick & the Encrypted Notes
Nov 13, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria