Cold Case Files Cold Case Files

REOPENED: DNA SPEAKS: Death Downstream

Oct 15, 2026 · 35m

Summary

This episode details the 1993 murder of Shauna Yandel in Yakima, Washington, whose body was found in the river after she was last seen with her boyfriend Travis. After Travis and another suspect were cleared, the case went cold until forensic supervisor Kristen Schaefer located missing DNA samples in 2005. A CODIS hit in 2009 identified Clayton Stafford, leading to his arrest and conviction for aggravated first-degree murder. The story concludes with the emotional reactions of Shauna’s sister, Shannon, who finally received closure after nearly two decades of uncertainty.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: Progressive Insurance and Ernesta Rugs Content warning and introduction to the cold case Discovery of the body in the Yakima River Shauna Yandel's life and relationship with Travis Travis reports missing person and identifies the body Travis becomes the primary suspect Investigation shifts to Kenny Madden Sponsor: Rosetta Stone language learning Discovery of tire iron in Wilkie family car Case goes cold and emotional toll on family DNA samples found and CODIS hit identifies Clayton Stafford Arrest of Clayton Stafford and family reaction Prosecution builds the case for trial Sponsors: Fabletics and Pluto TV Trial testimony and guilty verdict Victim impact statement and closure for the family Sponsors: Pluto TV, Progressive, and Xocova
Listen ad-free on Castria