Cold Case Files Cold Case Files

REOPENED: A Husband's Secret

Aug 27, 2026 · 15m

Summary

This episode details the 1970 murder of Barbara Jean Gallagher in Sedalia, Missouri, and its resolution three decades later. After neighbor Donald Vanderbent confessed to his wife Julie in 1999, she assisted police in building a case against him. Vanderbent was arrested, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, and was sentenced to 25 years in prison, finally bringing closure to the cold case.

Topics discussed

Sponsors: BetOnline and Amazon Music The Murder of Barbara Jean Gallagher in 1970 Investigation Clues and Donald Vanderbent's Fingerprints Vanderbent's Confession to His Wife Julie Sponsor: Wayfair Halloween Decor Julie Goes Undercover to Gather Evidence Connecting the Florida Case to the Missouri Cold Case Arrest and Interrogation of Donald Vanderbent Conviction, Sentencing, and Julie's Reflection Credits and Pluto TV Sponsorship Sponsor: Discount Tire
Listen ad-free on Castria