Celtic Board Launch New Fan Proposal - Does It Go Far Enough and Will It Change Anything?
Summary
John McGinley and Hamish Carton critique Celtic’s recent performance against Kilmarnock, expressing concern over the team’s inconsistent style and Martin O’Neill’s questionable squad management. The hosts then analyze the newly released terms of reference for the "Celtic Connect" fan advisory board, highlighting significant issues regarding the lack of independence, club control over meeting minutes, and the exclusion of established supporter organizations.
Topics discussed
Sponsors and show introduction
Show agenda and live chat engagement
Reflections on the Kilmarnock match performance
Concerns over upcoming fixtures and team consistency
Managerial stability and player selection debates
Substitution tactics and Kasper Højlund's role
Fan support for Højlund and tactical pairing with Duran
Squad management: Tenekti vs Hassan and work rate issues
Critique of transfer window signings and bench depth
Season context and league standing assessment
Midfield issues and January transfer window prospects
Defensive concerns and positive performances (Carter-Vickers, Johnson)
Sponsorship segments
Celtic Connect: New fan proposal terms and structure
Composition of the fan advisory board representatives
Criticism of lack of independence and control by the club
Comparison with Rangers and exclusion of established fan groups
Transparency concerns regarding meeting minutes and accountability
Communication channels and the need for robust frameworks
Club discretion in removing reps and international fan issues
Conclusion: Balancing positives with the need for credibility
Listen ad-free on Castria