Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford

The Pedlar and the Witch | Halloween Season

Oct 23, 2026 · 39m

Summary

Tim Harford recounts the 1612 Pendle witch trials, analyzing how a peddler’s stroke was misinterpreted as witchcraft and how social plausibility structures fueled the accusations against figures like Alice Nutter. The episode explores the historical context of King James’s anti-witch beliefs and contrasts modern skepticism with contemporary persecution in parts of the world. It also examines the paradox of author Charlotte Meredith, who campaigns for a formal pardon for the accused while simultaneously publishing a book based on her mother’s spiritualist interviews with the dead.

Topics discussed

Sponsorships: ChatGPT, Chase, and UnitedHealthcare Setting the scene: Pendle Hill, 1612 The encounter: A peddler and a teenage girl King James and the fear of witchcraft The peddler's collapse and the accusation Alison's confession and the source material Cunning folk and the rivalry of Old Demdike Sponsorships: Chase, Before the Moment, and Head Start Modern tourism in the Pendle Valley The great assembly and the plot to free witches The enigma of Alice Nutter Historical fiction and new evidence New testimonies from the accused and the peddler The method: Spiritualism and the author's mother Sponsorships: Chase, Before the Moment, and Head Start Scottish apology and the Justice for Witches campaign Public belief in the supernatural today The trial: Evidence and the identity parade Plausibility structures and modern witchcraft persecution The execution and the Charlotte Meredith paradox Credits, Patreon, and final sponsorships

More from Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford

Vasa: History's Least Successful Warship
Nov 20, 2026
Introducing… Are we Doomed? Just a Minor Sun Explosion
Nov 17, 2026
Bravo, Comrade Lysenko! The Man who Failed to Feed the USSR
Nov 13, 2026
Why Milk Cartons "Scared the Bejesus Out of a Generation" - with Roman Mars
Nov 6, 2026
Why Miners See Ghosts | Halloween Season
Oct 30, 2026
Listen ad-free on Castria