Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford

Arsenic and Lace: The Trial of the Yorkshire Witch - with Maddy Pelling

Jul 31, 2026 · 43m

Summary

Tim Harford interviews historian Maddie Pelling about her book on 18th-century hoaxes, focusing on Mary Bateman, a Leeds witchfinder who murdered clients with arsenic. Pelling explores how Enlightenment-era chaos fueled deception, drawing parallels to modern scams and the human desire for hope. The discussion also covers listener questions on political forgeries and the psychology behind why people fall for cons.

Topics discussed

Intro and Ad Breaks Story Intro: Rebecca Perrigo and the Curse Interview Intro: Hoaxes in the Enlightenment The Bottle Conjurer Hoax Mary Bateman: Early Life and Rise to Power Mid-Roll Ad Breaks The Kitchen Sisters and the Egg Hoax The Murder of Rebecca Perrigo Mary Bateman's Trial and Execution Legacy: Anatomy and Public Display Q&A: Modern Scams and Redeemed Hoaxers Q&A: Political Forgeries and Schadenfreude Outro and Credits
Listen ad-free on Castria