Bulwark Takes Bulwark Takes

BREAKING: JD Vance Privately Advised Hillary Clinton's Campaign in 2016 (w/ Chris Whipple)

Sep 16, 2026 · 26m

Summary

Chris Whipple discusses his Vanity Fair profile of JD Vance’s formative years at Yale Law School, highlighting his mentorship under Amy Chua and the influence of Peter Thiel. The episode explores the contradiction between Vance’s anti-elite rhetoric and his reliance on elite networks, including a previously unreported instance where he back-channeled advice to the Clinton campaign in 2016. Whipple also analyzes the complex dynamic between Vance and Donald Trump, noting that while Trump initially valued Vance’s recantation of past criticisms, their relationship is fraught with tension over t…

Topics discussed

Sponsor: Aquahor Hydrating Daily Lotion Sponsor: ChatGPT for Business Introduction of guest Chris Whipple and the article Vance's arrival at Yale Law and Amy Chua's role Vance's anger, outsider status, and meeting Usha The dynamic between Vance and Usha in law school Vance's search for meaning and paternal figures Influence of Peter Thiel and the search for faith Contradictions in Vance's anti-elite populism Debate on Vance as opportunist vs. true believer Vance's back-channel advice to the Clinton campaign in 2016 Sponsor: Casper Mattresses Details of Vance's calls to Jake Sullivan Trump's opinion of Vance and their personal dynamic Vance's recantation of past criticisms of Trump Vance's defense of Trump's Charlottesville remarks Future tensions between Trump and a rising Vance Comparison to Mike Pence and potential for independence Vance's political baggage and inability to break with Trump Does Vance stand for anything? Ideology vs. opportunism Conclusion and promotion of Chris Whipple's Substack Sponsor: Journavics Pain Relief Sponsor: ChatGPT Work
Listen ad-free on Castria