Brooke and Jeffrey’s show features a prank phone tap where Vito and Vino, hired by neighbor Alyssa, call guests to critique their previous Halloween costumes and enforce stricter dress codes. The hosts mock the callers’ dated suggestions and the guests’ outdated ideas, leading to a comedic exchange about sangria and potential "peanut butter and jelly" outfits. The segment concludes with the reveal that the call is a live radio prank, leaving the unsuspecting guest, Erin, shocked by the entire ordeal.