Brooke and Jeffrey Brooke and Jeffrey

Second Date Update: Something Sticky Down There

Oct 30, 2026 · 18m

Summary

Listener Sean calls in to explain why his date, Allie, has ignored him for five days after they met at a horror film festival. The hosts call Allie, who reveals she was offended when Sean assumed her natural goth style was a Wednesday Addams costume. The situation takes a comedic turn when Allie admits she is more interested in Sean’s friend, James, who secretly obtained her number while Sean was in the restroom.

Topics discussed

Intro: Looney Tunes and dating help Halloween costumes and social media promo Listener Sean's story: meeting in the dark The horror film fest and the sticky seat Banter in the theater and the reveal The bar date and the wingman's exit The ghosting and Sean's confusion Recap and preparing to call Allie Calling Allie: initial impressions The 'Wednesday' misunderstanding explained Sean's reaction and the apology struggle Allie's offense and Sean's defense The twist: Allie chooses the friend The friend's number and segment conclusion
Listen ad-free on Castria