Brooke and Jeffrey Brooke and Jeffrey

Second Date Update: Froyo Fun

Nov 4, 2026 · 18m

Summary

Listener Amanda shares her story of meeting Steve after being attracted to his humorous name-pronunciation prompt on a dating app. Their date involved an intense fro-yo session and five hours of dancing, but Steve reveals he had arranged for a bouncer to deny them entry as a passive-aggressive exit strategy. The plan failed due to a miscommunication, leading to an awkward confrontation where Amanda confronts Steve about his indirect rejection.

Topics discussed

Intro: New charity merch and St. Jude's Listener Amanda's unusual attraction to a profile The 'Steve' voice prompt and humor The Froyo date and Amanda's connoisseurship Going to the club and the bouncer connection Five hours of dancing and the ghosting Pre-call banter and setting expectations Calling Steve: Initial reactions and context Steve's perspective on the Froyo conversation The failed bouncer exit strategy Amanda confronts Steve on the call The daylight savings excuse and final verdict Outro: Personality matches and show plug
Listen ad-free on Castria