Reverse Trick or Treating
Oct 29, 2026 · 16m
Summary
Brooke and Jeffrey return their annual "Reverse Trick-or-Treating" segment, sending their technical director Ashton into a suburban neighborhood in a princess costume to convince homeowners to swap places for Halloween. Accompanied by his father, Ashton attempts to persuade strangers to let him inside while they stand outside to trick-or-treat, but faces repeated rejections and awkward encounters. The episode concludes with the duo laughing at their third consecutive year of failure and joking about future strategies.
Topics discussed
Sponsorships: Direct Support and ChatGPT for Teens
Intro to Reverse Trick-or-Treating segment
Ashton's strategy and princess costume reveal
Ashton's dad joins the mission
Approaching the first house with Christmas decorations
First attempt: Rejected by a housekeeper
Asking random dog walkers for leads
Commercial break and recap of failures
Second attempt: The house with the Subaru
Closest success: Polite rejection from homeowner
Third attempt: Construction workers and garage door
Neighbors stop to observe and Ashton's defeat
Return to studio and social media promotion
Listener feedback and blaming the 'one percenters'
Future plans: Brooke's involvement and new costumes
Sponsorships: ChatGPT, Direct Support, and Lincoln
Listen ad-free on Castria