In this "Brooke and Jeffrey" episode, the hosts prank call a man named Johnny, posing as a cosmetic surgery facility to trick him into paying for his ex-girlfriend's piercing. After successfully manipulating Johnny into admitting he suggested the piercing, the hosts reveal the call is a prank and expose that his ex was caught cheating on her new boyfriend. The segment concludes with the hosts mocking Johnny's gullibility and his refusal to pay for the procedure.