Brooke and Jeffrey Brooke and Jeffrey

Awkward Tuesday: Haunting of Boyfriends Past

Oct 27, 2026 · 18m

Summary

In this Halloween edition of Awkward Tuesday Phone Call, listener Amy confronts her ex-boyfriend Max after he repeatedly posts old photos of them together on social media. The call reveals that Max has been lying to his current girlfriend, claiming Amy is dead to avoid jealousy. Brooke and Jeffrey help Amy expose the deception, leading Max to admit the truth and agree to delete the posts.

Topics discussed

Sponsored read: Eczema treatment with Eucris Sponsored reads: PNC Bank and Discover Cash Back Card Sponsored read: Ring home security and cameras Promo for The Head Start podcast season 4 Intro to Awkward Tuesday Halloween edition Listener Amy calls in about her ex haunting her Amy explains ex Max posts old Halloween photos Hosts discuss motive and plan to call Max Commercial break and return to the call Hosts advise Amy to flatter Max to get answers Amy calls Max; he denies stalking and interest Amy confronts Max about posting photos; he stalls Amy threatens to contact Max's girlfriend Reveal: Max told his girlfriend Amy is dead Max explains he killed Amy to stop jealousy Max agrees to delete photos and stop the lie Outro and host banter after the call Sponsored read: Ring home security Sponsored reads: Hero Cosmetics and PNC Bank Sponsored read: Underdog sports betting app Sponsored read: Just Another Day in CA
Listen ad-free on Castria