Brooke and Jeffrey Brooke and Jeffrey

Battle of the Tinder Dates: Halloween Edition

Oct 28, 2026 · 7m

Summary

In this Halloween-themed episode of Battle of the Tinder Dates, hosts Brooke and Jeffrey judge two contestants, Amy and Sticky Nicky, who share their most tragic dating stories from the spooky season. The segment features horror-themed anecdotes, including a date who carved his ex's face into a pumpkin and another who accidentally removed his real teeth along with his vampire costume. Amy is ultimately declared the winner for her story about a fake exorcism, while the episode is supported by sponsors like PNC Bank and Ring.

Topics discussed

Sponsored: Eczis for eczema treatment Sponsored: Granger cleaning supplies Sponsored: PNC Bank and Discover Card Sponsored: Underdog fantasy sports app Intro to Battle of the Tinder Dates Halloween edition Meet contestants Amy and Sticky Nicky Round 1: Amy's ex-face pumpkin story Round 1: Nicky's dead bride date story Round 2: Amy's fake exorcism date Round 2: Nicky's Dracula denture story Round 3: Amy's fake cop date story Round 3: Nicky's trick-or-treater surprise Judges' verdict and winner announcement Sponsored: Zepbound for sleep apnea Sponsored: Underdog fantasy sports app Sponsored: Ring home security cameras Sponsored: Hero Mighty Cleanser face wash Sponsored: PNC Bank closing ad
Listen ad-free on Castria