Second Date Update Classics: Real Life Ghosting + Halloween Ghostface Ditcher
Oct 31, 2026 · 36m
Summary
Brooke and Jeffrey host a Halloween-themed episode featuring two "Second Date Update" segments. The first involves a listener who lost his date in a haunted house, only to discover she left because she mistook him for a suspect in a police sketch. The second segment reveals a mix-up at a Halloween party where a woman dressed as Ghostface made out with the wrong Jason Voorhees, leading to a comedic confrontation with the real Jason.
Topics discussed
Halloween intro, social media shoutouts, and show announcement
Catheter joke and setup for haunted house date story
Mike's story: Meeting Dakar and losing her in the haunted house
Theories on why Dakar disappeared and calling her
Dakar reveals she thought Mike was a serial flasher
Mike's defense, police lineup joke, and second date arrangement
Transition to new segment: Hookup Halloween
Jenna's story: Meeting Drew (Jason) at a Halloween party
Recap of Jenna and Drew's night and preparing to call Drew
Calling Drew: He reveals Jenna went home with a different Jason
Jenna and Drew react to the mix-up; Drew has moved on
Wrap-up, costume banter, and final sign-off
Listen ad-free on Castria