Second Date Update Classic: Secret Garden Shocker
Summary
Listeners Justin and Katie discuss their awkward second date, which began when Justin faked gardening interest to meet her at a community garden. The situation escalates when they reveal both sets of parents used a matchmaking app to orchestrate the encounter without Katie’s full knowledge. Despite Katie initially liking Justin’s honesty, she rejects a third date after learning about the parental interference, leaving Justin single again.
Topics discussed
Sponsors: Grainger, Discover, Botox, T-Mobile
Intro and Second Date Update setup
Justin meets Katie in a community garden
The secret parent matchmaking app revealed
Hosts debate revealing the truth to Katie
Calling Katie: She likes Justin but is hesitant
Justin confesses the setup; Katie rejects him
Post-call analysis and Justin's failure
Sponsors: Vinted, JBL, EpGliss, Total Wine, Vela, Pfizer, Resorts World
Listen ad-free on Castria