Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update Brooke and Jeffrey: Second Date Update

Second Date Update Classic: How Dare You Heart Me

Aug 24, 2026 · 16m

Summary

Brooke and Jeffrey help listener Aiden understand why his date, Kim, stopped responding after a fun night that included him jokingly punching himself. They call Kim, who reveals she felt undervalued because Aiden switched from writing long, flattering texts to simply reacting with heart emojis to her photos. After Aiden apologizes and promises to provide more verbal validation, Kim agrees to a second date paid for by the show.

Topics discussed

Sponsor reads: ChatGPT, Discover, UnitedHealthcare, Grainger, and Epclusa Intro: Welcome to Second Date Update and listener comments Aiden's story: Meeting Kim online and the 'do it 100%' bio The date: Drinks, the self-punch joke, and going back to his place The conflict: Kim's cold texts and the 'whatever' response Hosts analyze the situation and decide to call Kim Calling Kim: She explains the vibe shift and lack of validation Aiden joins the call: Misunderstanding about emoji vs. paragraphs Resolution: Aiden apologizes and they agree to a second date Sponsor read: Vinted secondhand fashion app Outro: Hosts discuss the outcome and promote the segment Final ads: Epclusa, Kesimpta, Pennzoil, M&M's, and PNC Bank
Listen ad-free on Castria