Second Date Update Classics: Real Life Ghosting + Halloween Ghostface Ditcher
Summary
In this Halloween-themed episode, hosts Brooke and Jeffrey discuss two "Second Date Update" stories. First, a listener named Mike is ghosted by his date Dakar at a haunted house after she mistakes him for a serial flasher based on a police sketch. Second, Jenna, dressed as Ghostface, realizes she made out with a different Jason Voorhees impersonator at a party, not her crush Drew, who had already hooked up with another woman.
Topics discussed
Sponsored segment: Kesimpta for multiple sclerosis
Sponsored segment: Just Another Day in CA
Sponsored segment: Botox for chronic migraine
Show intro and social media shoutouts
Teaser: Haunted house incident and second date update
Mike's story: Meeting Dakar and planning the date
Mike's story: Drinks and the haunted house reservation
Mike's story: Losing track of Dakar inside the haunted house
Mike's story: Searching for Dakar and her disappearance
Hosts react to Mike's story and prepare to call Dakar
Dakar's side: The police sketch and her decision to leave
Dakar's side: Explaining her fear and lack of communication
Dakar's side: Details on the suspicious police sketch
Confronting Mike: The flasher accusation and denial
Hosts defend Mike and propose a police lineup
Resolution: Mike agrees to the lineup and gets a second date
Dakar agrees to participate in the police lineup
Sponsored segment: Head Start Embracing the Journey podcast
Wrap-up of Mike and Dakar's storyline
Transition to new segment: Spooky season romance
Jenna's story: Meeting Drew at a Halloween house party
Jenna's story: Discussing horror movie costumes
Jenna's story: The night of the party and a rival suitor
Jenna's story: Leaving the party and lack of contact
Hosts attempt to call Drew for the first time
Calling Drew: Confusion and lack of memory
Drew's side: Claiming Jenna left with another Jason
Jenna and Drew confront each other on air
Revealing the truth: Multiple Jasons and Drew's other date
Drew admits to hooking up with another woman
Jenna's reaction and the 'mystery of foot' joke
Sponsored segment: Head Start Embracing the Journey podcast
Hosts discuss the ethics of Jenna's situation
Sponsored segment: Just Another Day in CA
Sponsored segment: Underdog digital card packs
Sponsored segment: Career opportunities and independence
Listen ad-free on Castria