Second Date Update: Something Sticky Down There
Oct 30, 2026 · 18m
Summary
Listener Sean recounts meeting Allie at a horror film fest, but she stopped responding after he jokingly called her "Wednesday" based on her goth attire. When the hosts call Allie, she reveals she found the comment offensive and is actually interested in Sean's friend James. The segment concludes with a twist where James had already given Allie his number, securing a new date despite the initial misunderstanding.
Topics discussed
Discover Cash Back Card advertisement
Eczema treatment advertisement for Ebclis
Intro and Halloween costume reveal
Listener Sean's story: meeting a woman in the dark
Sean explains the horror film fest setting
The date: banter in the theater and moving to a bar
The wingman's failed attempt to leave the table
Sean's confusion over the lack of response
Recap of the story and the mystery
Preparation to call Allie for answers
Allie joins the call and shares her perspective
The misunderstanding: 'See you Wednesday' comment
Debate on whether the comment was offensive
Sean joins the call to apologize
Allie expresses frustration and Sean's awkward response
Sean doubts Allie's story; hosts intervene
Allie chooses Sean's friend James instead
Reveal: James had Allie's number all along
Segment conclusion
Discover Cash Back Card advertisement
Cachava nutrition shake advertisement
Post-segment discussion on the outcome
Zepbound sleep apnea medication advertisement
California manufacturing and agriculture promotion
Pfizer vaccine reminder advertisement
Listen ad-free on Castria