FULL SHOW: Pet Food Tasting Dare, Naughty Pumpkin Song + Bridesmaid Confession (9/17/26)
Summary
Brooke and Jeffrey host a special episode featuring a "Miss America" trivia game where the hosts and a guest answer questions about pageant history. They also air a "Masked Speaker" confession from a bridesmaid who accidentally damaged a wedding dress, leading to a memorable reception mishap. The show includes a prank phone call targeting a *Sex and the City* fan and a "You Would Not Dare" challenge where the hosts sample and review various types of pet food.
Topics discussed
Intro and Sherwin-Williams Color of the Year
Debate on the new color choice
Miss America history and pageant scandals
Trivia: The horse banned from Miss America
Game: Guessing the pageant talent acts
Game: 1940 Miss America festival events
Shock collar and William Shatner song
Bride's wedding day camel story
Masked Speaker: Bridesmaid rips wedding dress
Prank call: HBO capping Seinfeld viewership
Studio chaos and photo shoot confusion
Summer wrap-up and challenge intro
You Would Not Dare: Eating mystery pet food
Pet food challenge continues with more hosts
Aftermath and beard cleanup
Teasers for upcoming segments
TikTok Click Shock: Singing Halloween pumpkin
Flight attendant hygiene tips for tray tables
Homeless man plays piano and gets home
Listener call: Japan trip and trivia game
Listen ad-free on Castria