Kenzie's Krimes: The Hauntings of the Crawfordsville Rotary Jail
Summary
In this Spooktober edition of Kenzie’s Crimes, Brian and Kenzie explore the history of Indiana’s first Rotary Jail, a unique structure designed to minimize guard staffing. They recount the tragic 1885 hanging of John Coffey, a developmentally disabled man who likely confessed falsely to murder, which ended in a gruesome three-attempt execution. The episode details subsequent ghost sightings of Coffey and the sheriff, who allegedly still haunt the jail grounds.
Topics discussed
Intro: Spooktober edition and Hell's Gate sponsor
History of the Crawfordsville Rotary Jail
Jail mechanics, cost-saving design, and inmate anecdotes
Safety hazards and body parts caught in the mechanism
Commercial break and return to the story
Recap and the McCullen murders case
John Coffey's trial and first public execution setup
The failed hanging and 12-minute strangulation
Ghost sightings: hitchhiking and train encounters
Modern hauntings at the museum and closing thoughts
Sponsor: Shopify
Sponsor: Dan Bongino Show
Sponsor: Pastor Matt Hagee's book
Sponsor: Optilume BPH
Listen ad-free on Castria