FROM THE VAULT: Goosebumps Readalikes with Brian McAuley
Oct 13, 2026 · 57m
Summary
Host and guest Brian McCauley discuss R.L. Stine’s Goosebumps series, sharing nostalgic memories of the books and TV show. They pair specific Goosebumps titles with recommended adult, middle grade, and YA horror novels, such as How to Sell a Haunted House and Small Spaces. The conversation also touches on related horror media like Fear Street and Friday the 13th, concluding with a segment on the host’s current obsession with a popular gossip podcast.
Topics discussed
Introduction and the Phoebe Bridgers meme
Nostalgia for Goosebumps books and early memories
The Goosebumps TV show and favorite episodes
Discussing plot twists and specific book memories
Fan favorites and merchandise collection
The Goosebumps Disney+ series and Fear Street movies
Comparing horror movie sequels and franchises
Acquiring Fear Street books and local book sales
Pairing Night of the Living Dummy with adult horror
Pairing Deep Trouble with Merciless Waters
Pairing The Scarecrow Walks at Midnight with Small Spaces
Pairing Werewolf of Fever Swamp with Sawtooth
Pairing Welcome to Dead House with YA novels
Pairing Piano Lessons Can Be Murder with Violent Faculties
Pairing Monster Blood 2 with Frostbite
Recommendation for the podcast 'Gossip'
Feature on the horror store Terror Trader
Final Girl song selection and guest social media
Closing remarks and show notes
Listen ad-free on Castria