Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan Body Bags with Joseph Scott Morgan

Woman Found Beaten, Bloody, Unconscious, Outside Her Home! Who Killed Katie Garcia?

Sep 15, 2026 · 44m

Summary

Hosts Joseph Scott Morgan and Brother Dave analyze the suspicious death of Kansas City massage therapist Katie Garcia, who was found beaten and partially undressed in her yard. They scrutinize the husband’s claim of a fall, noting the victim’s extremely high blood alcohol level and the failure to perform a sexual assault kit. The discussion highlights critical investigative gaps, including the lack of a blood trail and the delay in scene processing, while exploring how the medical examiner will determine if the case is a homicide.

Topics discussed

Intro and Underdog Fantasy Sports ad SimpliSafe security system ad Airtasker gig economy ad Case introduction: Katie Garcia Hosts discuss personal experiences with intoxicated friends Overview of the victim's death and context Timeline of events on July 30th Discovery of the victim in the yard Investigating the victim's work and neighborhood Comparing to other domestic violence cases Reliance on the husband's account of events Forensic analysis of the victim's condition Questioning the lack of a sexual assault kit Sponsorship breaks (Underdog, SimpliSafe, Airtasker) Medical vs forensic focus in initial treatment Forensic evidence collection and DNA analysis Physical trauma and the husband's legal counsel Legal and privacy reasons for missing evidence Blood alcohol content and its implications Sponsorship breaks (Underdog, SimpliSafe, Airtasker) Scene investigation and search for clothing Police access to the home and warrant issues Analysis of the time gap and suspect behavior Forensic testing of blood and urine samples Medical records and hospital stay analysis Physical changes in comatose patients Closing remarks and final sponsorships
Listen ad-free on Castria