New York, New York with Lin-Manuel Miranda
Sep 6, 2026 · 2h 2m
More Comedy podcasts
Summary
Griffin and David discuss Martin Scorsese’s 1977 film New York, New York, featuring guest lyricist Lynn Ahrens. They analyze the movie’s troubled production, its status as Scorsese’s only major commercial failure, and the dynamic between Robert De Niro and Liza Minnelli. The conversation highlights the film’s controversial editing, which removed key sequences like "Happy Endings," and explores how the iconic title song was born out of creative conflict.
Topics discussed
Movie taglines and initial impressions
The dramatic challenge of the film's concept
Comparison to The Last Waltz and Jonathan Demme
Robert De Niro's roles and rehearsal techniques
Grandpa Claus and De Niro as Santa Claus
Financial failures and commercial success
Star Wars impact and United Artists decisions
Disney legends and Bob Costas anecdotes
Bob Costas story and West Side Diner
Jack and the Beanstalk and Disney adaptations
Guest introduction and New York New York confession
Orphaned songs and John Kander's involvement
Jimmy as an asshole in the show and movie
Liza Minnelli's early talent and philosophy
Hollywood vs. real New York City
Scorsese's direction and song rewrites
Top of the Heap and Scorsese's style
Redemptive final hour and cut sequences
Cut sequences and pacing issues
Happy ending sequence as a movie in miniature
Sponsor segment: digital town and pop culture
Scorsese's early career and Irvin Winkler
Valentine to Hollywood and Xanadu reference
Unlikable protagonist and De Niro's charm
Documentary style within a 40s film
Oscar nerds and cultural references
Evolving style from 40s to 50s
Mick Jagger and plane of existence anecdotes
Liza Minnelli's autobiography and improvisation
Sympathetic actor under siege
De Niro's saxophone performance
Scorsese's personal life and the film
Delivery room scene and audience reaction
Sponsor segment: glasses and virtual try-on
Scorsese's only musical and diegetic music
Anti-musical attempts and barriers to entry
De Niro's age and Sex in the City arc
Drug-fueled mess and Fred Ebb's stories
Tony win and Broadway ticket prices
Liza Minnelli's state and improvisation
Bobby Fosse and unique star qualities
Liza Minnelli's career after the film
Autobiography confession and movie adaptation
Medium choice and lighter roles
Laszlo Kovacs and Last Waltz connection
22 takes and Liza Minnelli's tears
La La Land comparison and artistic passions
Meat nasty and relationship dynamics
Grandest sets and meat cute continuation
Plot movement and bar scene
Manhunter new cut and empathy for child
John Kander email and WWII service
Editing challenges and De Niro's performance
Repetitive plot and beautiful visuals
Quiet intensity and De Niro's humor
Cameo appearances and club ownership
Harlem number and pure jazz performance
Unstudied test and cut opening sequence
Liza Minnelli's title song performance
Bananas and Best Original Song nominees
You Light Up My Life and infamous winner
Cutting down to good stuff and re-release
Scorsese's self-assessment and biting off more
Sponsor segment: Resident Evil Patreon series
Star Wars box office and Jaws comparison
Darth Vader and Luke Skywalker favorites
Package deal and poor reviews
Sorcerer and New Hollywood strikes
Roller Coaster and 4D experience
Influence on Babylon and La La Land
Academy Award nominations and unique talent
Trains and Octet edit hiatus
Making fun and Amy Heckerling reference
Credits and production team
More from Blank Check with Griffin & David
Listen ad-free on Castria