UNSOLVED: The Murder Of Karitha and Jamaya Carroll
Summary
Host Amara details the 2009 murders of Karetha Carroll and her three-year-old daughter Jamiah in Cary, Mississippi. The episode covers the investigation’s missteps, including a rejected murder-suicide theory and the arrest of Karetha’s uncle for obstruction. It highlights how the case collapsed when a key witness recanted her confession, leaving the killings unsolved after nearly two decades.
Topics discussed
Wealthfront ad and disclaimer
Introduction to Black Girl Gone and the Carroll case
Profile of Karetha Carroll and her life in Cary, MS
The night of the murder and discovery of the bodies
Crime scene investigation and lack of forced entry
Autopsy details and brutality of the attack
Early investigation and ruling out close suspects
Sponsor reads: BetterHelp, Shopify, Zenni, Quince
Murder-suicide theory and arrest of uncle Tony Stamps
Josephine Warren's confession and subsequent recantation
Local rumors, potential motives, and family's beliefs
Case remains unsolved and appeal for information
Afterthoughts promo and final sponsor reads
Listen ad-free on Castria