The Case of the Missing Canoe Part 1 - Crime Bizarre
Aug 5, 2026 · 32m
Summary
Mick Molloy and Titus O’Reily dissect the bizarre life of John Darwin, who faked his death by kayak to claim insurance money after his property investments failed. With his wife Anne’s complicity, Darwin hid in a secret passage in their home while posing as a lodger. His deception unravels when he obsessively plays an online game, leading to a disastrous romantic encounter in Kansas City and eventual flight to Panama.
Topics discussed
Introduction and Bizarre Plus membership promo
John Darwin's early life and failed business schemes
Painting gnomes and door-to-door sales ventures
Property portfolio collapse and mounting debts
The plan to fake death for insurance fraud
Executing the disappearance and the massive search
Hiding in plain sight with a secret passage
Official declaration of death and insurance payout
Creating a new identity from a deceased infant
Close calls with neighbors and former colleagues
Online romance with Kelly Steele in Asheron's Call
Failed Kansas City trip and move to Panama
Episode wrap-up and teaser for next week
Listen ad-free on Castria