Big Take Big Take

The Diamond Industry’s Battle for Your Ring Finger

Oct 16, 2026 · 12m

Summary

The diamond industry faces a crisis as lab-grown alternatives, now chemically identical and significantly cheaper, erode the market for mined stones. Host Stacey Vanek-Smith explores this disruption through interviews with industry leaders and startups like Eternava, which creates diamonds from loved ones' ashes. While natural diamond giants like De Beers fight back with new marketing narratives and authenticity scanners, consumer preferences are shifting toward affordable, ethically produced synthetic options.

Topics discussed

Setting the scene: Diamond industry leaders at an Italian dinner The rise of lab-grown diamonds and celebrity endorsements Introduction to the story and the value of diamond narratives De Beers' marketing history and the 'A Diamond is Forever' slogan Shifting consumer preferences and price gaps between natural and lab-grown How the pandemic and online shopping accelerated lab-grown demand Inside Eternava: Growing diamonds from ashes and memories Plummeting prices and the $12 Walmart diamond earrings De Beers CEO Al Cook on authenticity and the risks of fake natural stones Diamond-Proof technology and the launch of 'Desert Diamonds' Addressing the stigma of blood diamonds and ethical mining standards The geological argument for natural diamonds and closing credits
Listen ad-free on Castria