Between the Devil Between the Devil

The Fear Archive Presents: Black Christmas vs. Daniel LaPlante

Jul 29, 2026 · 1h 1m

Summary

Hosts Amanda Kagawada and Mike Asip explore the chilling parallels between the 1974 horror film *Black Christmas* and the crimes of Daniel LaPlante. They discuss LaPlante’s early “frogging” behavior, where he hid in the walls of the Bowen family’s home, and his subsequent triple murder. The episode examines whether LaPlante was inspired by the film’s “killer in the attic” trope, analyzing how reality may have imitated this seminal slasher movie.

Topics discussed

Toyota National Sales Event Ad Intro: The Fear Archive and Black Christmas Danny LaPlante: The Frogger and Psychological Warfare Holiday Horror Theme and Episode Setup The Bowen Family Intrusion and Discovery The Gustafson Murders and LaPlante's Sentencing Defining Frogging and Historical Context LaPlante's Potential Influence from Black Christmas Discussion on Intent and Comparison to Other Killers Forewarning Signs and Juvenile Justice Failures LaPlante's Move to Montana and Escalation Debate on Rehabilitation vs. Life Imprisonment Horror Tropes: Calls from Inside the House Black Christmas Film Analysis: Cast and Production Legacy of Black Christmas and Slasher Genre Sound Design and The Blurring of Fiction and Reality Plot Breakdown: The Agnes and Billy Mystery Other Films: Parasite and Hider in the House Evidence of LaPlante Watching the Film Speculation on Ted Bundy and Modern Influences Living in Crime Scenes and Psychological Impact Personal Stories: Intrusion and Fear of Basements Nightmares and The Leaking Fuel Tank Conclusion: Horror as a Mirror of Reality Credits and Production Team
Listen ad-free on Castria